News

Coalition backs school phone restrictions but warns blanket ban would fail disabled pupils

The Scottish Children’s Services Coalition (SCSC), an alliance of leading providers of specialist care and education for vulnerable children and young people, has backed Scottish Government plans to restrict mobile phones in schools, but warned that a blanket ban would discriminate against disabled pupils and those with additional support needs (ASN), who may rely on their phones to learn, communicate and stay safe.

In its response to the Scottish Government’s consultation on Restricting mobile phones in Scotland’s schools, which closes on Tuesday 17 November, the coalition recognises the damaging impact phones are having on classroom behaviour, concentration and pupil wellbeing, including distraction, disruption and online bullying.

It comes as figures lay bare the scale of disruption and violence in Scotland’s classrooms:

However, it warns that a one-size-fits-all ban would leave behind the very children who most need support, and is calling for:

  • Exceptions written into the legislation itself, not left to the discretion of individual schools or councils
  • Clear protection for disabled pupils and those with ASN, as well as pupils with medical conditions and young carers
  • Access agreed through a child’s existing support plan, involving the child and their family, and reviewed regularly
  • No restriction on wearables or devices used for medical or accessibility purposes

For many pupils, a phone is not a distraction but an essential tool. It can be their voice through augmentative and alternative communication (AAC) apps, a lifeline for monitoring type 1 diabetes or epilepsy, a link to hearing aids and cochlear implants, or a screen reader, magnifier or text-to-speech tool for pupils with visual impairments or dyslexia. For some autistic pupils, or those experiencing anxiety, it forms a planned part of how they manage their day in school.

The coalition stresses that schools already have duties to make reasonable adjustments for disabled pupils under the Equality Act 2010, and that children’s rights are now enshrined in Scots law through incorporation of the UN Convention on the Rights of the Child (UNCRC).

An SCSC spokesperson said:

“Phones in classrooms are fuelling disruption, damaging concentration and exposing children to bullying, and we support action to tackle this.

“But a blanket ban for all would be a blunt instrument. For a disabled child who speaks through an app, or a pupil who depends on their phone to manage a medical condition, taking it away is not about behaviour – it is about removing their right to learn and participate on an equal footing.

“Exceptions must be written into the law, so that no child is left at the mercy of a postcode lottery. Get this right, and we can have calmer classrooms without shutting out the children who already face the greatest barriers.”

Related Posts

Next/Prev Posts

linkedin facebook pinterest youtube rss twitter instagram facebook-blank rss-blank linkedin-blank pinterest youtube twitter instagram